Choosing between the Benelli Supernova and the Remington 870 is a classic conundrum for shotgun enthusiasts. Both are legendary pumps, renowned for their reliability and versatility, but they cater to slightly different needs and preferences. This in-depth comparison will dissect their key features, helping you decide which shotgun reigns supreme for your specific requirements.
Key Differences: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Both shotguns excel in their respective areas, but understanding their differences is crucial for making an informed decision. Let's break it down:
1. Action & Feel:
-
Remington 870: Known for its smooth, classic pump action. The action is generally considered lighter and quicker than the Supernova, making for faster follow-up shots. However, this can also feel less substantial to some shooters. The 870's design is time-tested and feels familiar to many.
-
Benelli Supernova: Features a distinctive, heavier, inertia-driven pump action. This results in a more robust and controlled feel, especially during rapid firing. The action is generally perceived as slightly slower, but many appreciate the more solid recoil management. The Supernova's unique design emphasizes ergonomics and comfort.
2. Ergonomics & Features:
-
Remington 870: A relatively simple design. While comfortable for many, the ergonomics aren't as extensively customizable as the Supernova. It's a utilitarian design focused on functionality. Upgrades and customization options are widely available, however.
-
Benelli Supernova: Boasts an incredibly adjustable stock and forend, allowing for significant customization to perfectly fit the shooter's physique. Its ComforTech system is designed to reduce recoil and muzzle jump. This translates to increased shooter comfort and improved follow-up shot capabilities, particularly during extended shooting sessions. The pistol grip is also highly regarded for its comfort and control.
3. Reliability & Durability:
-
Remington 870: A workhorse known for its incredible reliability. Millions have been produced, proving its resilience and ability to function under various conditions. Its simple design contributes to its easy maintenance and repair.
-
Benelli Supernova: Also highly reliable, though perhaps not with the same legendary status as the 870. Its robust construction and modern engineering contribute to its durability. The inertia-driven system is known for its reliability in adverse conditions, though it's generally more complex to maintain than the 870.
4. Price:
-
Remington 870: Generally more affordable than the Benelli Supernova, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious buyers.
-
Benelli Supernova: Typically commands a higher price point, reflecting its advanced features, superior ergonomics, and generally higher-quality construction.
5. Versatility:
-
Remington 870: A highly versatile platform, available in a wide range of configurations for hunting, home defense, and competition shooting. Its widespread popularity means a massive aftermarket support system with readily available accessories.
-
Benelli Supernova: Similarly versatile, readily adaptable to various shooting disciplines. The adjustable stock and forend allow for optimal customization regardless of the application.
Which Shotgun is Right for You?
The "better" shotgun depends entirely on your individual needs and preferences.
Choose the Remington 870 if:
- You prioritize affordability and a classic, time-tested design.
- You want a lightweight and fast-cycling action.
- You need a shotgun with readily available parts and a large aftermarket support system.
Choose the Benelli Supernova if:
- You value superior ergonomics and adjustability.
- You want a shotgun with reduced recoil and muzzle jump.
- You're willing to pay a premium for enhanced comfort and features.
- You prioritize a robust and controlled shooting experience.
Ultimately, handling both shotguns is crucial before making a decision. Visit a local gun store or shooting range to get a feel for each one and determine which fits your style and shooting needs best. This hands-on experience will significantly inform your final choice.
