Choosing between the Glock 17 Gen 4 and Gen 5 can be tricky, even for experienced Glock enthusiasts. Both are excellent handguns, but subtle differences cater to specific preferences and shooting styles. This in-depth comparison will highlight the key distinctions, helping you decide which generation best suits your needs.
Key Differences: A Head-to-Head Analysis
The Glock 17 Gen 5 boasts several improvements over its predecessor, the Gen 4. While the Gen 4 remains a reliable and popular choice, the Gen 5 refines the platform with several noteworthy upgrades.
1. The Trigger: Enhanced Smoothness and Consistency
- Gen 4: Features a rougher, more textured trigger surface, designed for improved grip. It's a reliable trigger but some find it less refined than the Gen 5.
- Gen 5: Boasts a smoother, more polished trigger face, contributing to a crisper, more consistent trigger pull. This improvement is widely appreciated by shooters seeking a refined trigger experience. The trigger's overall feel is noticeably improved, enhancing accuracy and shot control.
2. The Slide: Ambidextrous Considerations
- Gen 4: Includes interchangeable backstraps, allowing for customization of the grip. It features a noticeably more textured slide. The slide also includes a rail for mounting accessories, like lights or lasers.
- Gen 5: Eliminates the need for interchangeable backstraps, instead opting for a more aggressively textured grip. The Gen 5 features a smoother slide with front serrations. The lack of the rail helps streamline the gun's profile, reducing weight and allowing for easier cleaning and maintenance. It also features ambidextrous slide stop levers.
3. The Recoil Spring Assembly: Simplified Design
- Gen 4: Uses a dual recoil spring assembly.
- Gen 5: Employs a single, redesigned recoil spring assembly, reducing parts and making maintenance even simpler. This contributes to a smoother, more consistent recoil impulse for many users.
4. The Barrel: A Refined Profile
- Gen 4: Uses a standard Glock barrel with polygonal rifling.
- Gen 5: Features a Marksman barrel. The Marksman barrel boasts a tighter tolerance which promises improved accuracy.
5. The Magazine Release: Ambidextrous Functionality
- Gen 4: Offers a reversible magazine release, catering to both right-handed and left-handed shooters. Requires a simple tool for alteration.
- Gen 5: Includes an ambidextrous magazine release, a significant improvement for left-handed users, eliminating the need for any adjustments.
Which Generation is Right for You?
The best Glock 17 for you depends on your individual needs and preferences.
Choose the Glock 17 Gen 4 if:
- You prefer a more textured grip.
- You require interchangeable backstraps for customized fit.
- Budget is a primary concern (Gen 4s are often slightly cheaper).
- You’re more comfortable with a slightly less polished trigger.
Choose the Glock 17 Gen 5 if:
- You value a smoother, more refined trigger pull.
- You want a more streamlined, lighter slide.
- Ambidextrous controls are essential for you.
- You appreciate a simplified recoil spring assembly and enhanced maintenance.
- You prioritize accuracy.
Conclusion: A Matter of Personal Preference
Ultimately, both the Glock 17 Gen 4 and Gen 5 are exceptional handguns. The Gen 5 represents a refined evolution of the platform, addressing some minor criticisms while maintaining the core reliability Glock is known for. The best choice comes down to your individual shooting style, preferences, and budget. Consider the features outlined above, handle both models if possible, and make an informed decision based on what feels most comfortable and effective for you.
