Choosing between the Remington 870 and the Mossberg 590 is a rite of passage for shotgun enthusiasts. Both are legendary pump-action shotguns with a rich history and unwavering reliability, making the decision far from straightforward. This in-depth comparison will dissect key features, performance aspects, and user experiences to help you determine which shotgun reigns supreme for your needs.
Design and Ergonomics: A Tale of Two Approaches
The Remington 870 and Mossberg 590 boast distinctly different designs, impacting their feel and operation.
Remington 870: The Classic
The Remington 870, with its decades-long legacy, features a sleeker, more refined profile. Its receiver is noticeably smaller, contributing to a generally more compact feel. The action is known for its smooth, controlled cycling, often described as having a more "refined" feel. However, some find the safety placement less intuitive compared to the Mossberg 590. The 870's follower is also known for a more pronounced click when loading shells, a point of contention for some users.
Mossberg 590: The Workhorse
The Mossberg 590 presents a more utilitarian design, with a larger, more robust receiver. This translates to a slightly heavier feel and a more pronounced "clunk" during operation. Its larger receiver generally allows for easier internal modifications and customization. The top-mounted safety is universally praised for its intuitive operation. The 590's shell loading is known for its positive and reliable action.
Reliability and Durability: Built to Last
Both shotguns are renowned for their ruggedness and reliability. They've earned their places in law enforcement, military, and hunting circles for their ability to function flawlessly under demanding conditions. However, subtle differences exist:
Remington 870: Proven Performance
The Remington 870's reputation precedes it. Millions have been sold, and countless testimonials speak to its unwavering reliability. While not immune to malfunctions (like any firearm), its consistent performance across a vast range of ammunition types and conditions is legendary.
Mossberg 590: Unwavering Strength
The Mossberg 590 shares the same reputation for reliability. Its robust construction makes it a favorite among users who demand uncompromising durability. The slightly more substantial construction might offer a marginal edge in extreme conditions, though both shotguns are remarkably durable.
Features and Customization: Tailoring to Your Needs
Both shotguns are highly customizable, but their approaches differ:
Remington 870: A Legacy of Aftermarket Support
The Remington 870 benefits from an enormous aftermarket support network. Finding stocks, barrels, sights, and other accessories is exceptionally easy. This makes the 870 highly versatile, adaptable to various applications, from hunting to home defense.
Mossberg 590: Ease of Modification
The Mossberg 590's simpler design and larger receiver often make internal modifications (like installing ghost rings or changing the safety) a simpler process for gunsmiths and experienced DIYers.
Price and Value: Finding the Best Deal
Price points vary significantly depending on the model, configuration, and retailer. Generally speaking, both shotguns offer excellent value for their respective price ranges. Finding a used example of either can be a cost-effective way to obtain a highly reliable shotgun.
Conclusion: The Verdict
Ultimately, the "better" shotgun—Remington 870 or Mossberg 590—depends entirely on individual preferences and intended use. The Remington 870 offers a more refined feel, smoother cycling, and a vast aftermarket. The Mossberg 590 provides a more robust build, easier customization options, and often a more intuitive safety. Both are exceptional shotguns; careful consideration of your specific needs will guide you to the perfect choice. Handling both, if possible, before making a decision is highly recommended.
