Choosing the right concealed carry pistol is a deeply personal decision, demanding careful consideration of size, weight, capacity, and personal shooting preferences. Two popular contenders often top the list for compact 9mm options: the Ruger EC9s and the Ruger EC9. While seemingly similar at first glance, key differences exist that significantly impact their suitability for different users. This detailed comparison will help you determine which pistol best fits your needs.
Size and Weight: A Key Differentiator
The most obvious difference lies in their dimensions. The Ruger EC9s is significantly smaller and lighter than the EC9. This makes the EC9s far more comfortable for deep concealment, especially for individuals with smaller hands or those who prefer a lighter carry experience. The reduced size, however, comes at the cost of slightly reduced grip surface area.
- EC9s: Designed for maximum concealability, prioritizing a slim profile. Ideal for appendix carry or pocket carry.
- EC9: Offers a slightly larger grip, providing a more substantial feel and potentially improved control during shooting for users with larger hands.
Table: Ruger EC9s vs. EC9 Dimensions (Approximate)
| Feature | EC9s | EC9 |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Length | ~5.5 inches | ~6.0 inches |
| Height | ~3.8 inches | ~4.5 inches |
| Width | ~0.9 inches | ~1.0 inches |
| Weight | ~13.7 ounces | ~17.5 ounces |
Capacity and Reliability: Similar Performance, Different Features
Both pistols utilize the same reliable 9mm Luger cartridge and generally boast similar reliability. However, the EC9s offers a slightly lower magazine capacity. This difference, while seemingly minor, is crucial for concealed carry users who prioritize ammunition capacity.
- EC9s: Typically comes with a 6+1 round capacity.
- EC9: Typically comes with a 7+1 round capacity.
It's essential to note that both firearms are known for their robust construction and reliability. Ruger's reputation for building dependable firearms extends to both the EC9 and EC9s models. Regular cleaning and maintenance are still essential for optimal performance regardless of the model chosen.
Handling and Shootability: A Matter of Preference
The larger grip of the EC9 generally translates to improved handling and control, particularly during rapid fire or for shooters with larger hands. The more substantial grip allows for a better and more secure hold. The EC9s, while smaller, remains manageable for most shooters but may be less forgiving for those less experienced or with smaller hands. Ultimately, personal preference and hand size will greatly influence the preference between these two pistols.
Concealability and Everyday Carry: The EC9s Takes the Lead
When it comes to concealed carry, the EC9s is the clear winner. Its smaller size and lighter weight make it significantly easier to conceal comfortably under various clothing layers. The EC9, while still concealable for some, is less ideal for deep concealment and might print more noticeably under clothing.
Conclusion: The Right Choice Depends on Your Needs
The decision between the Ruger EC9s and the EC9 hinges largely on individual needs and priorities. If superior concealability and a lighter carry weight are paramount, the EC9s is the better option. If slightly improved handling, a larger capacity, and a more substantial feel are prioritized, the EC9 might be the more suitable choice. Consider your hand size, intended carry method, and overall comfort when making your decision. Consider renting both models at a local range to experience the differences firsthand before purchasing.
